Log inStart free

Picktime® vs Square Appointments: Free to book. Different ways to pay

Both Picktime and Square Appointments offer free scheduling, but they handle payments differently. Picktime lets you accept payments through PayPal on its Free plan, while paid plans also support Stripe and Square. Square Appointments uses Square to process customer payments, with transaction fees applying to each payment. Picktime doesn’t charge an additional percentage of your bookings, but payment processor fees still apply. The better choice depends on how you accept payments and what your business needs to schedule.

Start freeCompare side by side
  • Free forever
  • No card required
  • Your name on the page
At a glance

Picktime vs Square Appointments: Different Tools, Different Trade-Offs

Picktime and Square Appointments compared on the free plan, what gets charged, card processing fees, resources, waitlists, cancellation rules, AI call answering and hardware
 PicktimeSquare Appointments
Free Plan with no end dateFree forever, no card requiredFree at $0/month per location
What gets chargedTeam members and locationsA subscription for each location, plus card payment fees
Payment Processing FeesStandard processing fees applyFree plan: 2.6% + 15¢ per in-person card payment and 3.3% + 30¢ per online card payment. Fees vary by plan.
Rooms and equipment are bookable resources, with no overlapping bookings.Yes, Independent or Staff-AssignedResource management starts on Premium at $149/month per location
Waitlist That Keeps Spots FilledIt closes when booked. Pro Plan lets waitlists fill openings.Available on Plus and Premium
Cancellation rules by serviceYes. Set the cancellation window for each service.Plus and Premium include cancellation policies
AI that answers calls and books appointmentsYes, available around the clock on a paid plan.Available through NextClient AI, a separately priced third-party integration.
Card readers, terminals, and POSNoYes, built and supported by Square

Checked 1 September 2026 against picktime.com/pricing and squareup.com, with the card rates re-read on 8 September 2026 against Square’s own fee page. Every cell is read off what each vendor publishes. A cell reading “Not listed” means the row is not in that vendor’s own plan comparison, which is not the same as saying the product cannot do it.

Where each one wins

Picktime stays on the same bill. Square takes a cut of each payment.

Neither pricing model is hiding anything. The difference is what happens when you make more sales. One cost grows with your takings, while the other stays the same. That makes the math worth checking before the feature list.

Where Picktime wins

If you take regular payments and want to choose your processor

  • Picktime’s free online booking charges are based on team members and locations, not your sales. You pay the same scheduling cost in busy or quiet months, with no percentage taken from payments.
  • Keep the processor you already use. Picktime scheduling software lets you use PayPal on the free plan. However, Stripe or Square starts on Starter. Your payment setup stays familiar, including payments and deposits.
  • Picktime’s Free plan supports two classes with capacity limits and three bookable resources for rooms or equipment. You can manage appointments that require both a team member and a resource. When classes reach capacity, Pro adds waitlists that can automatically fill available spots after cancellations.
  • Configure booking rules and cancellation windows for your services, so customers know when they can cancel or reschedule. This helps you manage availability without having to handle every schedule change manually.

Where Square Appointments wins

If you already sell at the counter or are just getting started

  • Square Appointments is free at $0/month per location, and you can take card payments from day one. For a new business, that means no monthly software bill while you start selling.
  • Bookings and checkout live in one system with Square. You can manage appointments, card payments, products, and receipts together, which helps if you sell products alongside services.
  • Square booking offers card readers, terminals, and registers for in-person payments. Its hardware integrates with appointments, giving businesses a single system for bookings, payments, and checkout.
  • Lower Processing Rates on Paid Plans. Square’s standard in-person processing fees decrease from 2.6% + 15¢ on Free to 2.5% + 15¢ on Plus and 2.4% + 15¢ on Premium. Businesses processing more than $250,000 annually may qualify for custom pricing, but eligibility and rates must be confirmed with Square.

The calls nobody is free to answer: Picktime’s AI receptionist picks up around the clock and several calls at once, takes the caller’s details, and ends in a booking in the same calendar as everything else, with a transcript of the call in your dashboard afterwards.

Cost

See where the pricing starts to differ

Picktime’s Free plan includes three team members, three resources, two locations, and unlimited appointments without a monthly subscription. Paid plans offer additional scheduling features and higher limits rather than charging based on your sales volume. Picktime supports PayPal payments on Free, with Stripe and Square available on paid plans. Standard transaction fees still apply through your chosen payment provider, so include those costs when comparing Picktime with Square Appointments.

The Square Appointments pricing structure combines scheduling subscriptions with payment processing. Square Free costs $0 per month per location, Plus costs $49, and Premium costs $149. In-person card processing costs 2.6% + 15¢ on Free, 2.5% + 15¢ on Plus, and 2.4% + 15¢ on Premium. Online payments cost 3.3% + 30¢ on Free and 2.9% + 30¢ on paid plans. Manually entered or saved-card payments cost 3.5% + 15¢, while international cards incur an additional 1.5% fee. Your total cost depends on your subscription, locations, payment methods, and transaction volume.

To see which platform costs less, compare the total yearly expense of each. Add Picktime’s subscription cost, if any, to the processing fees charged by your chosen payment provider. Then calculate Square’s subscription fees and payment processing charges based on the same number of transactions, average booking value, and payment methods. Picktime may offer better value when its Free plan covers your scheduling needs, but the final difference depends on the processing rates you pay. Both platforms have free scheduling options, so comparing the complete cost gives you a more accurate picture than looking at subscription prices or transaction fees alone.

See Picktime pricing
Before you commit

Want the Real Cost? Look Beyond the Headline Price

If you take deposits online, do not compare only the in-person rate. Check the online rate too.

The online rate is where the plans really differ.

Square’s in-person processing fees range from 2.6% + 15¢ on Free to 2.4% + 15¢ on Premium. Online payment fees drop from 3.3% + 30¢ on Free to 2.9% + 30¢ on Plus and Premium. Deposits collected through a Square online booking page generally use online payment rates, so businesses collecting deposits regularly should include these fees in their total costs.

All pricing here is based on U.S. rates.

Square’s rates vary by country, and cards issued outside the U.S. add 1.5%. If many customers use foreign cards, include that extra fee when comparing your total costs.

Picktime sends confirmations for free. Reminders cost extra.

Picktime’s free booking sends a confirmation email when someone books, even on the Free plan. Reminders sent the day before are available on paid plans, as is SMS. If reducing no-shows is important to you, include these costs when comparing the two options rather than looking at the subscription alone.

Capacity Stops Bookings. A Waitlist Keeps Them Moving.

Picktime’s Free plan lets you set a class capacity so bookings stop when all spots are filled. Its Pro plan adds a waitlist, allowing the next person to take a spot when someone cancels. Square offers waitlists on Plus and Premium, but its appointment waitlist is not available for class bookings. If you only need to limit class size, both platforms support capacity limits without a waitlist.

Switching

From Square to Picktime: Move the Booking, Not the Whole Business

01

Decide Where Payments Stay

Moving bookings is simple. Changing your payment setup takes more thought, especially if you use Square hardware. So first decide on payments first, then move your calendar.

02

Rebuild What Customers Can Book

Your services and hours are simple to rebuild. Rooms, equipment, and class capacities need a fresh setup. You can also export customers from Square scheduling and import them.

03

Switch Bookings Without Switching Payments

You can switch to Picktime’s Free plan for appointment scheduling and continue taking Square payments separately in person. If you want customers to pay through Picktime’s booking page using Square, you’ll need Starter or Pro. Connecting Square for payments does not automatically transfer or sync your existing Square Appointments calendar, so you’ll need to set up your appointments and availability in Picktime separately.

Deciding

Picktime vs Square appointments: Which One Fits How You Work?

  • Choose Picktime if…

  • The one that usually decides it You process enough card payments that processing fees can cost more than a subscription.

    Choose Picktime

  • You already have a payment processor and want to keep using it with your booking system.

    Choose Picktime

  • Book rooms, equipment, or classes without upgrading to the highest plan.

    Choose Picktime

  • Keep the same monthly cost whether business is busy or quiet.

    Choose Picktime
  • Choose Square Appointments if…

  • Start with low sales and get the software and card reader without a monthly fee.

    Choose Square Appointments

  • You sell products and services and want one system for bookings, inventory, and sales.

    Choose Square Appointments

  • You want card readers on the counter, with support from the company behind them.

    Choose Square Appointments
Questions

FAQs for Picktime vs. Square Appointments

Does Square Appointments offer a free plan?

Yes, Square Appointments offers a free plan with no monthly subscription fee. It includes online appointment booking and payment processing, but card transaction fees still apply. Square also offers paid plans with additional scheduling features and different processing rates, so your total cost depends on your payment volume and business needs.

Does Picktime charge a fee for each booking?

Picktime does not charge a fee simply for creating an appointment. For online payments, Picktime charges a 0.5% booking commission on PayPal transactions on Free and Starter. Stripe and Square payments on Starter have no Picktime booking commission, and Pro has zero booking commission across supported payment providers. Separate payment processing fees still apply.

Can I accept payments through Square with Picktime?

Yes, Picktime lets you connect your Square account to accept online credit and debit card payments or deposits through your Booking Page. Square payments are available on Starter and Pro, while Free supports PayPal. You can manage appointments in Picktime while Square processes your payments. For the latest plan features and limits, see Picktime pricing.

Can I switch from Square Appointments to Picktime?

Yes, you can switch from Square Appointments to Picktime. Export your customer contacts from Square as a CSV file and import them into Picktime, then set up your services, staff availability, and appointments. The Square payment integration does not automatically sync Square Appointment bookings with Picktime. You can continue using Square separately for in-person payments.

How do Picktime and Square Appointments compare for salon bookings and payments?

Picktime lets salons manage stylist schedules, appointments, rooms, equipment, and online payments through supported providers. Square Appointments combines staff scheduling, online booking, card payments, and POS hardware. Among Square Appointments alternatives, Picktime is a strong choice for salons that want flexible scheduling and payment processor options, while Square Appointments suits businesses that prefer integrated booking and in-person checkout.

Picktime against the rest

vs Calendlyvs Setmorevs SimplyBook.mevs Acuity Schedulingvs YouCanBook.mevs Zoho Bookingsvs Google Calendarvs Appointy

Rounded up elsewhere

Calendly alternativesSetmore alternativesAcuity Scheduling alternativesThryv alternativesBest free appointment schedulingBest free scheduling softwareBest appointment scheduling softwareBest scheduling appsBest online booking systemsBest for small businessBest class scheduling software

Let your business grow without adding a cut to every card payment. Start free.

Pay for your team and locations, keep your processor, and start free with no card required.

Start freeSee what each plan carries